Pharmaco-epidemiological and toxicological studies of snake envenomations in selected areas of Kenya
Abstract
Venomous stakes are snakes which have venom glands and specialized teeth for the injection
of the venom into the victims. Snake envenomation is a global problem with annual figures of
5 million envenomations, 40,000 or more deaths and about 100,000 people ending up with
severe sequelae. However, these figures are approximate as most countries do not possess
reliable epidemiological reporting systems. This also applies to Kenya where envenomations
occur but the precise data on frequencies, mortalities and factors associated with snake
envenomations are not well documented. This study was carried out to determine the
frequencies of envenomations, mortalities and factors responsible for snake envenomations.
Snake envenomation is treated using antivenoms. Antivenoms are made by milking venom
from the selected snakes and injecting it to an animal that will undergo an immune response
to the venom, producing antibodies against the active venom antigens.
The antivenoms are manufactured from venoms obtained from snakes specific to certain
regions. Due to regional 'venom specificity, these antivenoms may not be effective when used
in other countries. The purpose of the study was also to test the efficacy of two of the most
commonly used antivenoms in Kenya namely polyvalent antivenom I and polyvalent
antivenom II.
Epidemiological studies were carried out on snake envenomations 111 areas where
envenomations have been reported in Kenya, namely Kakamega, Kabarnet, Kapenguria and
Makueni over a 3 year period (January 2007 to December 2009). Secondary data from
hospital records were used to compile" frequencies of snake envenomations, mortalities and
antivenom administration. Semi structured questionnaires were administered to respondents
who included: doctors, clinical officers, nurses, hospital pharmacists and private pharmacists.
Information obtained on victims of envenomations were: age, gender, time of day, and season of the year when envenomations happen, occupation, part of the body bitten, access to
hospitals and the role of traditional healers. Data on availability, effectiveness of anti venoms
and challenges to antivenom use in the hospitals were also gathered using the questionnaire.
Acute toxicity studies were performed in mice using the venom of one of the most common
venomous snakes in Kenya, the black mamba (Dendroaspis polylepsis). These studies
included: the determination of the median lethal dose (LDso) of black mamba venom in mice
by the moving average method of Weil (1952). Other parameters studied in the toxicity study
were: symptoms of poisoning and the effects of the venom on hematological parameters.
Postmortem of dead and sacrificed animals was done to determine the gross pathological
effects of the venom. The LDso value of Black mamba venom (0.340mg/kg) was used to
determine the antidotal effectiveness of two polyvalent antivenoms labeled I and II currently
being used in Kenyan hospitals. This was done by administering high LDso values of the
venom followed by the antivenom to determine the effect of treatment on lethality of the
venom.
The results obtained from hospital records for envenomations showed that out of 176
envenomations there were only 4 mortalities (2.3%). Antivenoms although available were
administered to only a few patients i.e. 49/176 (27.8%). The survival rates were observed to be
high i.e. 125/127 (98%) even without antivenom administration. The antivenoms in use were
generally effective in treating snake envenomations.
In relation to factors influencing envenomations, findings in this study demonstrated that there
were no major differences in envenornations between either gender (males 90, females 86).
The age groups 1-15 years and 16-30 years were mostly envenomated with the former
contributing 41.4% and the latter contributing 31.8% of all the envenomations. These age
groups could also be more physically active than the other age groups. Envenornations OCCUlTedmainly in the bush and farms and affected mostly manual and agricultural workers.
This could be due to presence of many snakes in these areas and also failure to wear
protective clothing. Envenomations occurred mostly during dry seasons compared to rainy
seasons. The lower limbs were more envenomated than other parts of the body i.e. 75%
compared to 25% for other parts of the body. This could be due to easy accessibility of lower
limbs by the offending snake and failure to wear protective clothing (like shoes) by the
victims.
The two polyvalent antivenoms labelled I and II were found effective in protecting mice
against Black mamba venom. Antivenom I protected rmce at 3xLDso and antivenom II
protected mice at 3xLDso and 4xLDso. The black mamba venom exhibited neurotoxic
symptoms with no significant hemotoxicity. The neurotoxic symptoms exhibited during acute
toxicity included: analgesia, weakness and incordination, increased or decreased respiration.
Postmortem results indicated that black mamba venom mainly caused paralysis of smooth
muscles of the blood vessels 'in the liver, lungs, kidneys, gastrointestinal tract and the spleen
leading to congestion and the affected organs appearing darker than normal ones.
In conclusion, the results showed that mortalities as a result of envenomations were relatively
low, 4/l76 (2.3%) possibly because of the non-poisonous nature of the snakes involved.
Envenomations were influenced by various external factors and antivenoms 111 use were
effective but antivenom administration was restricted to a few patients.
Sponsorhip
University of NairobiPublisher
Department of Public Health, Pharmacology & Toxicology, University of Nairobi